PYQ Vault

Homi Bhabha Chemistry · Air, Water and Gases

Preparing and Testing Gases

Hydrogen is made from zinc and a dilute acid and burns with a pop; carbon dioxide is made from marble and dilute acid, collected in an upright jar and turns lime water milky; each common gas has its own test.

Why this matters

Six questions in the bank, five MODERATE and one HARD. Two are about hydrogen (why potassium and water are not used to make it, and the gas from aluminium foil in sodium hydroxide); three are about carbon dioxide (the right laboratory set-up, its melting and boiling facts, and whether it is denser than air); one asks which gas blackens lead acetate.

Concept 1 of 3: Preparing hydrogen and its properties

Many metals push hydrogen out of an acid. In the laboratory we want a steady, safe stream of it, so we use zinc, which reacts gently. Very active metals like sodium and potassium react so violently with water that the heat sets the hydrogen on fire.

Definition

  • Laboratory method: zinc granules with dilute sulphuric acid (or dilute hydrochloric acid).
  • Hydrogen hardly dissolves in water, so it is collected over water (by downward displacement of water).
  • Sodium and potassium are not used: their reaction with cold water is violent and gives out so much heat that the hydrogen catches fire.
  • Aluminium or zinc with sodium hydroxide solution also gives hydrogen.
  • Properties: colourless, odourless, the lightest gas, burns with a pop sound when a burning splint is brought near.
ReactantsGives hydrogen?Note
Zinc and dilute sulphuric acidYesThe usual laboratory method
Magnesium and dilute hydrochloric acidYesFast but safe
Aluminium or zinc and sodium hydroxide solutionYesA base can also free hydrogen from these metals
Sodium or potassium and cold waterYesNot used: violent, and the heat sets the hydrogen on fire
The reaction does happen; it is too dangerous to use.
Copper and dilute hydrochloric acidNoCopper is too unreactive
A metal that gives hydrogen too slowly or too violently is not used in the laboratory.
Practise this conceptself-check · 4 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

Homi Bhabha Class 9 · 2024 · Homi Bhabha Std IX (30 November 2024) · Q39Moderate

Example 1 · Air, Water and Gases · Preparing and Testing Gases

When we add aluminum foil to freshly prepared sodium hydroxide solution a gas is produced. Which of the following correctly states the property of this gas?

Thinking potassium does not react with water

Potassium reacts with cold water very violently. That, and the heat that ignites the hydrogen, is why it is never used to make hydrogen.

Saying hydrogen helps things burn

Hydrogen itself burns, with a pop. The gas that makes a glowing splint burst into flame is oxygen.

Concept 2 of 3: Preparing carbon dioxide and its properties

Drop marble chips into dilute acid and they fizz: the bubbles are carbon dioxide. Because this gas is heavier than air, it sinks to the bottom of an open jar and pushes the air out above it, so we collect it in a jar standing upright.

Definition

  • Laboratory method: marble chips (calcium carbonate) with dilute hydrochloric acid.
  • The thistle funnel must dip into the acid, so the gas cannot escape through it.
  • The delivery tube must end above the acid in the flask, so only gas enters it.
  • Carbon dioxide is about 1.5 times as dense as air, so it is collected in an upright jar by upward displacement of air, the tube reaching the bottom of the jar.
  • Properties: colourless, odourless, turns lime water milky, puts out a flame. Solid carbon dioxide (dry ice) turns straight into gas at −78.5-78.5 °C; it melts only under high pressure, at about −56.6-56.6 °C.
Part of the apparatusCorrect positionWhat goes wrong otherwise
Thistle funnelIts end dips into the acidGas escapes up the funnel
Delivery tube in the flaskEnds above the acidAcid is pushed out along the tube
Gas jarUpright, tube reaching its bottomThe heavy gas spills out of an upside-down jar
The same flask set-up is used for any gas made from a solid and a liquid without heating.
Practise this conceptself-check · 4 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

Homi Bhabha Class 9 · 2023 · Homi Bhabha Std IX (2023-24 competition) · Q37Moderate

Example 2 · Air, Water and Gases · Preparing and Testing Gases

Select the correct diagram for preparation of CO2\mathrm{CO_2} in laboratory.

Dipping the delivery tube into the acid

Only the thistle funnel dips into the acid. A delivery tube under the acid carries acid, not gas, out of the flask.

Thinking carbon dioxide is lighter than air

Carbon dioxide (molecular mass 44) is heavier than air (average about 29), so it is collected upward in an upright jar.

Giving carbon dioxide a melting point at normal pressure

At normal pressure dry ice does not melt: it turns straight into gas at −78.5 °C. Liquid carbon dioxide forms only under pressure.

Concept 3 of 3: Tests for common gases

Most gases are colourless, so you cannot tell them apart by looking. Each one, though, does something special: one pops, one relights a glowing stick, one turns lime water milky, one smells of rotten eggs. A test is just that special behaviour.

Definition

  • Hydrogen: burns with a pop when a burning splint is brought near.
  • Oxygen: makes a glowing splint burst into flame.
  • Carbon dioxide: turns lime water milky and puts out a flame.
  • Hydrogen sulphide: smells of rotten eggs and turns paper soaked in lead acetate black (lead sulphide, PbS).
  • Ammonia: sharp smell, turns moist red litmus blue.
  • Sulphur dioxide: sharp smell, turns acidified potassium dichromate from orange to green.
GasColour and smellTest
HydrogenColourless, no smellBurning splint: pop sound
OxygenColourless, no smellGlowing splint relights
Carbon dioxideColourless, no smellLime water turns milky
Hydrogen sulphideColourless, rotten egg smellLead acetate paper turns black
AmmoniaColourless, sharp smellMoist red litmus turns blue
Sulphur dioxideColourless, sharp choking smellAcidified potassium dichromate turns from orange to green
Nitrogen dioxideBrown, sharp smellIts brown colour
A brown gas is nitrogen dioxide; every other gas in this table is colourless.
Practise this conceptself-check · 4 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

Homi Bhabha Class 9 · 2018 · Homi Bhabha Std IX (6 October 2018) · Q55Moderate

Example 3 · Air, Water and Gases · Preparing and Testing Gases

Name the gas which turns moist lead acetate solution silvery black.

Using a glowing splint for hydrogen

Hydrogen is tested with a burning splint (it pops). A glowing splint that relights shows oxygen.

Mixing up the two sulphur gases

Hydrogen sulphide blackens lead acetate paper; sulphur dioxide turns acidified potassium dichromate green.

Summary — formulas & gotchas at a glance

A revision cheat-sheet for the formulas and gotchas above. Click any concept name to jump back to its full explanation.

Reference tables (3)

Preparing hydrogen and its properties5 rows
ReactantsGives hydrogen?Note
Zinc and dilute sulphuric acidYesThe usual laboratory method
Magnesium and dilute hydrochloric acidYesFast but safe
Aluminium or zinc and sodium hydroxide solutionYesA base can also free hydrogen from these metals
Sodium or potassium and cold waterYesNot used: violent, and the heat sets the hydrogen on fire
The reaction does happen; it is too dangerous to use.
Copper and dilute hydrochloric acidNoCopper is too unreactive
A metal that gives hydrogen too slowly or too violently is not used in the laboratory.
Preparing carbon dioxide and its properties3 rows
Part of the apparatusCorrect positionWhat goes wrong otherwise
Thistle funnelIts end dips into the acidGas escapes up the funnel
Delivery tube in the flaskEnds above the acidAcid is pushed out along the tube
Gas jarUpright, tube reaching its bottomThe heavy gas spills out of an upside-down jar
The same flask set-up is used for any gas made from a solid and a liquid without heating.
Tests for common gases7 rows
GasColour and smellTest
HydrogenColourless, no smellBurning splint: pop sound
OxygenColourless, no smellGlowing splint relights
Carbon dioxideColourless, no smellLime water turns milky
Hydrogen sulphideColourless, rotten egg smellLead acetate paper turns black
AmmoniaColourless, sharp smellMoist red litmus turns blue
Sulphur dioxideColourless, sharp choking smellAcidified potassium dichromate turns from orange to green
Nitrogen dioxideBrown, sharp smellIts brown colour
A brown gas is nitrogen dioxide; every other gas in this table is colourless.

Watch out for (7)

Test yourself on a real paper

Sit a past Homi Bhabha Class 9 paper, timed and marked the way the exam marks it. You see your score and every answer the moment you finish. Free to start.