PYQ Vault

Homi Bhabha Chemistry · Atomic Structure

Atomic Models and Subatomic Particles

Dalton, Thomson, Rutherford and Bohr each improved the picture of the atom, ending with a tiny positive nucleus of protons and neutrons and electrons in fixed shells; protons and neutrons are themselves made of quarks.

Why this matters

Seven questions in the bank, two EASY, four MODERATE and one HARD. Three are about the models of the atom (what Rutherford saw, Bohr's fixed orbits, which metal foil can be used), and four about the particles: what a quark is, which family protons belong to, how many electrons would make up a body, and why a neon sign glows.

Concept 1 of 2: Models of the atom from Dalton to Bohr

Rutherford fired alpha particles at a very thin gold foil. Nearly all of them went straight through, as if the foil were empty. A few bent away, and a very few bounced back, as if they had hit something tiny, heavy and positive. That tiny thing is the nucleus, and the rest of the atom is mostly empty space.

Definition

  • Rutherford's observations: most alpha particles passed straight through the gold foil; some were turned through small angles; a few through large angles; very few (about 1 in 20,000) bounced back.
  • Rutherford's conclusions: the atom is mostly empty space; its positive charge and nearly all its mass sit in a tiny nucleus; electrons move around the nucleus.
  • Gold was chosen because it is the most malleable metal and can be beaten into an extremely thin foil. Aluminium is also highly malleable, and its thin foil can also be used.
  • Bohr: electrons move only in certain fixed orbits (shells) with fixed energy. An electron cannot stay between two orbits; it jumps from one to another by taking in or giving out energy.
ScientistModel or discoveryMain idea
John DaltonAtomic theoryAtoms are tiny, solid and cannot be divided
J. J. ThomsonDiscovered the electron; plum pudding modelA sphere of positive charge with electrons stuck in it
Ernest RutherfordGold foil experiment; nuclear modelA tiny, dense, positive nucleus; the atom is mostly empty space
Niels BohrBohr modelElectrons move only in fixed orbits and cannot stay between them
James ChadwickDiscovered the neutronThe nucleus also holds neutral particles
Each model kept what the earlier one got right and fixed what it got wrong.
Practise this conceptself-check · 4 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

Homi Bhabha Class 9 · 2018 · Homi Bhabha Std IX (6 October 2018) · Q37Moderate

Example 1 · Atomic Structure · Atomic Models and Subatomic Particles

Read the following statements and choose the correct alternative. Statement I : Aluminium foil cannot be used in α - particle scattering experiment. Statement II : Aluminium is highly malleable metal.

Thinking most alpha particles bounced back

Most went straight through. Only very few, about 1 in 20,000, bounced back. That is why the nucleus must be tiny.

Thinking only gold foil works

Gold was chosen for being the most malleable metal, but thin aluminium foil can also be used to scatter alpha particles.

Giving Rutherford the fixed orbits

Rutherford found the nucleus. The idea that electrons stay in fixed orbits and cannot be between them is Bohr's.

Concept 2 of 2: Protons, neutrons, electrons and quarks

The atom is built from three particles. Protons and neutrons are heavy and sit in the nucleus; electrons are about 1836 times lighter and move around it. Protons and neutrons are not the smallest pieces: each is made of three quarks. Electrons are not made of anything smaller.

Definition

  • Proton: charge +1, mass about 1.67×10−241.67 \times 10^{-24} g, in the nucleus.
  • Neutron: no charge, mass almost the same as a proton, in the nucleus.
  • Electron: charge −1, mass about 9.1×10−289.1 \times 10^{-28} g (about 1836 times lighter than a proton), around the nucleus.
  • Quarks are fundamental constituents of matter. Protons and neutrons are each made of three quarks; particles made of quarks are called hadrons. The electron is not made of quarks: it belongs to another family, the leptons.
  • Discharge tubes (neon signs, fluorescent tubes) hold a gas at low pressure. A high voltage makes it conduct, and the moving charged particles (electrons and ions) make the gas glow.
  • To count particles in a mass, divide the total mass by the mass of one particle, in the same unit.

Number of particles in a mass

N=MmN = \frac{M}{m}
  • NNnumber of particles
  • MMtotal mass
  • mmmass of one particle, in the same unit as M

Worked example

Suppose a speck of dust of mass 9.1 mg were made only of electrons. The mass of one electron is 9.1×10−289.1 \times 10^{-28} g. How many electrons would it contain?
Practise this conceptself-check · 4 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

Homi Bhabha Class 9 · 2017 · Homi Bhabha Std IX (16 September 2017) · Q40Moderate

Example 2 · Atomic Structure · Atomic Models and Subatomic Particles

A student weighs 44 kg. Suppose his entire body is mode up of electrons. How many electrons are their in his body? [Mass of one electron = 88×10−2988 \times 10^{-29} gm]

Calling the electron a hadron

Hadrons are made of quarks, like the proton and the neutron. The electron is a lepton: it is not made of quarks.

Dividing kilograms by grams

Put the total mass and the mass of one particle in the same unit before dividing: 1 kg is 1000 g.

Thinking a discharge tube glows because the gas is hot

The gas is at low pressure and not strongly heated. It glows because charged particles move through it.

Summary — formulas & gotchas at a glance

A revision cheat-sheet for the formulas and gotchas above. Click any concept name to jump back to its full explanation.

Formulas (1)

Reference tables (1)

Models of the atom from Dalton to Bohr5 rows
ScientistModel or discoveryMain idea
John DaltonAtomic theoryAtoms are tiny, solid and cannot be divided
J. J. ThomsonDiscovered the electron; plum pudding modelA sphere of positive charge with electrons stuck in it
Ernest RutherfordGold foil experiment; nuclear modelA tiny, dense, positive nucleus; the atom is mostly empty space
Niels BohrBohr modelElectrons move only in fixed orbits and cannot stay between them
James ChadwickDiscovered the neutronThe nucleus also holds neutral particles
Each model kept what the earlier one got right and fixed what it got wrong.

Watch out for (6)

Test yourself on a real paper

Sit a past Homi Bhabha Class 9 paper, timed and marked the way the exam marks it. You see your score and every answer the moment you finish. Free to start.