PYQ Vault

Homi Bhabha Chemistry · Measurement of Matter

Laws of Chemical Combination

Mass is neither made nor lost in a reaction, a compound always holds its elements in the same proportion by weight, and that proportion comes straight from the atomic masses in its formula.

Why this matters

Four questions in the bank, three MODERATE and one HARD. One asks which laws a reaction confirms; the other three are about proportion by weight: the ratio of copper to oxygen in CuO, the compound whose ratio is 3 : 8, and a molecular formula worked back from a ratio and a molecular mass.

Concept 1 of 2: The three laws of chemical combination

Atoms are only rearranged in a reaction, never made or destroyed, so the total mass cannot change. And because a compound is always built from the same atoms in the same numbers, its elements are always in the same ratio by weight, wherever the sample came from.

Definition

  • Law of conservation of mass (Lavoisier): in a chemical reaction the total mass of the reactants used equals the total mass of the products.
  • Law of constant proportions (Proust): a pure compound always contains the same elements combined in the same proportion by weight, however it is made.
  • Law of multiple proportions (Dalton): when two elements form more than one compound, the masses of one element that combine with a fixed mass of the other are in a simple whole-number ratio.
  • Only the reactant that actually reacts counts. Any reactant left over is subtracted before you compare masses.
LawGiven byExample
Conservation of massLavoisier12 g of carbon burns completely in 32 g of oxygen to give 44 g of carbon dioxide
Constant proportionsProustPure water from any source has hydrogen and oxygen in the ratio 1 : 8 by weight
Multiple proportionsDaltonWith 12 g of carbon, 16 g of oxygen gives CO and 32 g gives CO₂: the oxygen masses are 1 : 2
Needs two different compounds of the same two elements.
A single reaction between two substances can show the first two laws, never the third.
Practise this conceptself-check · 4 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

Homi Bhabha Class 9 · 2021 · Homi Bhabha Std IX (19 December 2021, online) · Q41Moderate

Example 1 · Measurement of Matter · Laws of Chemical Combination

A student heats 25 gm of Reactant 'X' with 50 gm of reactant 'Y'. He Obtains 50 gm of proudct 'Z' and recovers 25 gm of unreacted 'Y'. Which of the following laws are confirmed in this reaction? I) Law of constant proportion. II) Law of Conservation of mass [Matter]. III) Law of multiple proportion.

Counting the leftover reactant

If some of a reactant is left unreacted, subtract it first. Only the mass that reacted must equal the mass of the product.

Finding multiple proportions in one reaction

The law of multiple proportions compares two or more compounds of the same two elements, such as CO and CO₂. One reaction making one product cannot show it.

Mixing up the scientists

Conservation of mass is Lavoisier's law, constant proportions is Proust's, and multiple proportions is Dalton's.

Concept 2 of 2: Proportion by weight from a formula

The formula tells you how many atoms of each element are in one molecule, and the atomic masses tell you how heavy each kind is. Multiply them and you have the weight of each element in one molecule. Their ratio is the proportion by weight, and it is the same in a speck or a sack of the compound.

Definition

  • For each element: atomic mass × number of atoms in the formula.
  • Write these masses as a ratio and simplify it.
  • If the options are in the form x : 1, divide both numbers by the second one.
  • Working back: to find which formula fits a given ratio and molecular mass, check each option's molecular mass first, then its mass ratio.

Proportion by weight of elements A and B in a compound

A:B=(atomic mass of A×nA):(atomic mass of B×nB)\text{A} : \text{B} = (\text{atomic mass of A} \times n_A) : (\text{atomic mass of B} \times n_B)
  • nAnAnumber of atoms of A in one molecule
  • nBnBnumber of atoms of B in one molecule

Worked example

Find the proportion by weight of nitrogen and hydrogen in ammonia, NH3\mathrm{NH_3}. (N = 14, H = 1)
Practise this conceptself-check · 4 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

Homi Bhabha Class 9 · 2021 · Homi Bhabha Std IX (21 November 2021, online) · Q40Moderate

Example 2 · Measurement of Matter · Laws of Chemical Combination

Name the compound which has proportion by weight of constituent element is 3:8

Using the number of atoms instead of their mass

Proportion by weight uses masses. Ammonia has 1 N atom to 3 H atoms, but by weight it is 14 : 3, not 1 : 3.

Forgetting to multiply by the number of atoms

In SO3\mathrm{SO_3} oxygen weighs 3×16=483 \times 16 = 48, not 16. Leaving out the 3 gives 2 : 1 instead of 2 : 3.

Stopping at a ratio that fits but a mass that does not

When working back to a formula, several formulas can share one ratio (CH and C2H2\mathrm{C_2H_2} both have C : H = 12 : 1). The molecular mass decides which one it is.

Summary — formulas & gotchas at a glance

A revision cheat-sheet for the formulas and gotchas above. Click any concept name to jump back to its full explanation.

Formulas (1)

  • Proportion by weight from a formula

    Proportion by weight of elements A and B in a compound

    A:B=(atomic mass of A×nA):(atomic mass of B×nB)\text{A} : \text{B} = (\text{atomic mass of A} \times n_A) : (\text{atomic mass of B} \times n_B)

Reference tables (1)

The three laws of chemical combination3 rows
LawGiven byExample
Conservation of massLavoisier12 g of carbon burns completely in 32 g of oxygen to give 44 g of carbon dioxide
Constant proportionsProustPure water from any source has hydrogen and oxygen in the ratio 1 : 8 by weight
Multiple proportionsDaltonWith 12 g of carbon, 16 g of oxygen gives CO and 32 g gives CO₂: the oxygen masses are 1 : 2
Needs two different compounds of the same two elements.
A single reaction between two substances can show the first two laws, never the third.

Watch out for (6)

Test yourself on a real paper

Sit a past Homi Bhabha Class 9 paper, timed and marked the way the exam marks it. You see your score and every answer the moment you finish. Free to start.