PYQ Vault

NEET Botany · Molecular Basis of Inheritance

Genetic Material and Replication

The experiments of Griffith, Avery, MacLeod and McCarty, and Hershey and Chase that showed DNA is the genetic material, why DNA is a better store than RNA and the RNA world, the central dogma, and semiconservative replication with the Meselson and Stahl experiment and the replication enzymes.

Why this matters

Eight NEET questions from 2021 to 2025. Hershey and Chase came up twice (NEET 2023 and NEET 2025), and NEET 2024 matched four scientists with their discoveries. NEET 2022 set the hardest question of the chapter: counting the E. coli cells free of heavy nitrogen after 60 minutes. Learn who did which experiment, on what, and what it proved. NEET 2023 also asked whether RNA mutates faster than DNA.

Concept 1 of 3: The search for the genetic material

Griffith saw that something from dead bacteria could change living ones, but he did not know what it was. Avery and his team found that the something was DNA, yet not everyone believed them. Hershey and Chase settled it by labelling a virus's DNA and its protein differently and watching which one went into the bacterium. Only the DNA did.

Definition

What NCERT says:

  • Frederick Griffith (1928) worked with Streptococcus pneumoniae in mice. The S strain forms smooth shiny colonies, has a polysaccharide coat and kills mice (pneumonia). The R strain forms rough colonies, has no coat and is harmless.
  • Live S kills mice; live R does not; heat-killed S does not. But heat-killed S plus live R kills mice, and living S bacteria are recovered from them. The R strain had been transformed by a transforming principle. Its chemical nature was not found.
  • Oswald Avery, Colin MacLeod and Maclyn McCarty (1933 to 1944) purified proteins, DNA, RNA and other substances from heat-killed S cells. DNA alone transformed R bacteria. Proteases and RNases did not stop transformation; DNase did. They concluded DNA is the hereditary material, though not all biologists were convinced.
  • Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase (1952) gave the unequivocal proof. They grew bacteriophages on a medium with radioactive phosphorus (labels DNA, which contains phosphorus) or radioactive sulfur (labels protein, as DNA has no sulfur). Steps: infection, blending, centrifugation.
  • Bacteria infected by phages with radioactive DNA became radioactive; those infected by phages with radioactive protein did not. So DNA, not protein, passes from virus to bacterium.
ScientistsYearWhat they showed
Frederick Griffith1928Transformation in Streptococcus pneumoniae: heat-killed S bacteria changed live R bacteria into SQ
NEET 2025: matched Hershey and Chase with confirming DNA as the genetic material, and Griffith with Streptococcus pneumoniae.
Avery, MacLeod and McCarty1933 to 1944The transforming principle is DNA: DNase stopped transformation
Hershey and Chase1952Unequivocal proof that DNA is the genetic material, using labelled bacteriophages
Watson and Crick1953The double helix, and the semiconservative scheme of replication
Meselson and Stahl1958Semiconservative replication of DNA in E. coli, using heavy nitrogenQ
NEET 2024: matched Griffith with transformation, Jacob and Monod with the lac operon, Khorana with the genetic code and Meselson and Stahl with semiconservative replication.
Taylor and colleagues1958Chromosomes of Vicia faba also replicate semiconservatively, using radioactive thymidine
Practise this conceptself-check · 5 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

NEET · 2023 · NEET (UG) 2023 — 07 May 2023 · Q106Moderate

Example 1 · Molecular Basis of Inheritance · Genetic Material and Replication

Unequivocal proof that DNA is the genetic material was first proposed by

Griffith never named DNA

Griffith showed transformation, but the biochemical nature of the transforming principle was not found by him. Avery, MacLeod and McCarty identified it as DNA.

Unequivocal proof came from Hershey and Chase

Avery's group concluded DNA was the hereditary material, but unequivocal proof came from Hershey and Chase (1952). Wilkins and Franklin gave X-ray data on DNA structure, not proof that DNA is the genetic material.

Phosphorus for DNA, sulfur for protein

Radioactive phosphorus labels DNA; radioactive sulfur labels protein. Swapping them reverses the whole argument.

Concept 2 of 3: DNA against RNA, the RNA world and the central dogma

A genetic material must copy itself, stay stable, change slowly and show itself as traits. Both DNA and RNA can copy themselves, but RNA is more reactive, so it breaks and mutates easily. That makes DNA the better long-term store, and RNA the better messenger. RNA probably came first; DNA evolved from it as a steadier store.

Definition

What NCERT says:

  • A genetic material must (i) be able to make its replica, (ii) be chemically and structurally stable, (iii) allow slow changes (mutation) needed for evolution, and (iv) be able to express itself as Mendelian characters.
  • RNA has a 2'-OH on every nucleotide, which makes it labile and easily degraded. RNA is also catalytic, hence reactive. DNA is less reactive and more stable; thymine in place of uracil adds to its stability.
  • RNA, being unstable, mutates faster; viruses with an RNA genome and a short life span mutate and evolve faster. Some viruses, such as Tobacco Mosaic Virus and QB bacteriophage, have RNA as their genetic material.
  • RNA can code directly for protein; DNA depends on RNA to make protein. So DNA is better for storing genetic information and RNA for transmitting it.
  • RNA world: RNA was the first genetic material. Metabolism, translation and splicing evolved around RNA. RNA acted both as genetic material and as a catalyst, but being reactive it was unstable. DNA evolved from RNA with chemical changes that made it more stable; being double stranded with a complementary strand, it also resists change by evolving a process of repair.
  • Central dogma (Francis Crick): genetic information flows DNA to RNA to protein. DNA copies itself by replication, makes RNA by transcription, and RNA makes protein by translation. In some viruses the flow is reversed, from RNA to DNA.
PointDNARNA
SugarDeoxyribose, no 2'-OHRibose with a 2'-OH, which makes it labile
Base not sharedThymine, which adds stabilityUracil
ReactivityLess reactive, more stableReactive and catalytic, so unstable
Rate of mutationSlowerFaster; RNA viruses evolve faster
Making proteinDepends on RNACan code for protein directly
Best suited forStoring genetic informationTransmitting genetic information
Step of the central dogma that makes itReplication (DNA from DNA)Transcription (RNA from DNA)Q
NEET 2021: the central dogma flow chart is replication, transcription, translation, protein. Transduction is not a step.
Practise this conceptself-check · 6 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

NEET · 2025 · NEET (UG) 2025 — 04 May 2025 · Q96Moderate

Example 2 · Molecular Basis of Inheritance · Genetic Material and Replication

Given below are two statements : Statement I : In the RNA world, RNA is considered the first genetic material evolved to carry out essential life processes. RNA acts as a genetic material and also as a catalyst for some important biochemical reactions in living systems. Being reactive, RNA is unstable. Statement II : DNA evolved from RNA and is a more stable genetic material. Its double helical strands being complementary, resist changes by evolving repairing mechanism. In the light of the above statements, choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below :

The 2'-OH makes RNA unstable

The extra 2'-OH on ribose makes RNA labile and easily degraded. It is a reason RNA is a poorer store, not a reason it is stable.

RNA came first

In the RNA world, RNA was the first genetic material and DNA evolved from RNA. DNA is the later, more stable store, not the older one.

Transduction is not in the central dogma

The central dogma is replication, transcription and translation. Transduction is gene transfer between bacteria by a virus and is never one of its arrows.

Concept 3 of 3: Semiconservative replication and the Meselson and Stahl experiment

When DNA copies itself, the two strands separate and each builds a new partner. So every new DNA keeps one old strand. Meselson and Stahl made the old strands heavy with heavy nitrogen and then let the cells grow on light nitrogen. The two heavy strands of each starting DNA never break, so they end up in two hybrid molecules however many times the cell divides. Everything else becomes light.

Definition

What NCERT says:

  • Watson and Crick proposed that the two strands separate and each acts as a template; each new double helix has one parental and one new strand. This is semiconservative replication.
  • Meselson and Stahl (1958) grew E. coli for many generations on 15NH4Cl^{15}\text{NH}_4\text{Cl} as the only nitrogen source, so 15N^{15}\text{N} entered its DNA. 15N^{15}\text{N} is a heavy isotope, not a radioactive one. Heavy and normal DNA are separated by centrifugation in a caesium chloride (CsCl) density gradient.
  • The cells were moved to 14NH4Cl^{14}\text{NH}_4\text{Cl}. E. coli divides in 20 minutes. After one generation (20 min) the DNA was all hybrid (intermediate density); after two generations (40 min) it was equal amounts of hybrid and light DNA.
  • The main enzyme is DNA-dependent DNA polymerase. E. coli, with 4.6×1064.6 \times 10^{6} bp, completes replication within 18 minutes, about 2000 bp per second. Deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates act both as substrates and as the source of energy.
  • The strands open only in a small region, the replication fork. DNA polymerase adds nucleotides only in the 5' to 3' direction, so replication is continuous on the template of polarity 3' to 5' and discontinuous on the template of polarity 5' to 3'. The discontinuous fragments are joined by DNA ligase.
  • DNA polymerase cannot start replication on its own. Replication begins at a definite origin of replication. In eukaryotes DNA replicates in the S phase; if the cell then fails to divide, the result is polyploidy.

Heavy-nitrogen DNA after n generations in light nitrogen

1 heavy DNA→2n DNA:2 hybrid+(2n−2) light1 \text{ heavy DNA} \rightarrow 2^{n} \text{ DNA}: \quad 2 \text{ hybrid} + (2^{n}-2) \text{ light}
  • nnnumber of generations in light nitrogen; one every 20 minutes for E. coli
  • hybridDNA with one heavy (old) strand and one light (new) strand
  • lightDNA with both strands made from light nitrogen

Worked example

E. coli with all its DNA in heavy nitrogen is moved to a light-nitrogen medium and grown for 80 minutes. What are the proportions of hybrid and light DNA?
Practise this conceptself-check · 6 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

NEET · 2022 · NEET (UG) 2022 — 17 Jul 2022 · Q191Hard

Example 3 · Molecular Basis of Inheritance · Genetic Material and Replication

Ten E.coli cells with 15N^{15}N - dsDNA are incubated in medium containing 14N^{14}N nucleotide. After 60 minutes, how many E.coli cells will have DNA totally free from 15N^{15}N?

Polymerase works 5' to 3' only

DNA-dependent DNA polymerase adds nucleotides only in the 5' to 3' direction, never 3' to 5' and never both ways. That is why one strand is made continuously and the other in pieces.

The two hybrid molecules never go away

However many generations pass, one heavy DNA leaves exactly 2 hybrid molecules; only the number of light molecules grows. Count hybrid cells as 2 for each starting DNA.

Heavy, not radioactive

15N^{15}\text{N} is a heavy isotope, not radioactive; it is detected by density in a CsCl gradient. Radioactive thymidine was used by Taylor on Vicia faba.

Ligase joins, polymerase builds

DNA ligase joins the discontinuous fragments. DNA polymerase builds the new strand but cannot start replication by itself and does not join fragments.

Summary — formulas & gotchas at a glance

A revision cheat-sheet for the formulas and gotchas above. Click any concept name to jump back to its full explanation.

Formulas (1)

Reference tables (2)

The search for the genetic material6 rows
ScientistsYearWhat they showed
Frederick Griffith1928Transformation in Streptococcus pneumoniae: heat-killed S bacteria changed live R bacteria into SQ
NEET 2025: matched Hershey and Chase with confirming DNA as the genetic material, and Griffith with Streptococcus pneumoniae.
Avery, MacLeod and McCarty1933 to 1944The transforming principle is DNA: DNase stopped transformation
Hershey and Chase1952Unequivocal proof that DNA is the genetic material, using labelled bacteriophages
Watson and Crick1953The double helix, and the semiconservative scheme of replication
Meselson and Stahl1958Semiconservative replication of DNA in E. coli, using heavy nitrogenQ
NEET 2024: matched Griffith with transformation, Jacob and Monod with the lac operon, Khorana with the genetic code and Meselson and Stahl with semiconservative replication.
Taylor and colleagues1958Chromosomes of Vicia faba also replicate semiconservatively, using radioactive thymidine
DNA against RNA, the RNA world and the central dogma7 rows
PointDNARNA
SugarDeoxyribose, no 2'-OHRibose with a 2'-OH, which makes it labile
Base not sharedThymine, which adds stabilityUracil
ReactivityLess reactive, more stableReactive and catalytic, so unstable
Rate of mutationSlowerFaster; RNA viruses evolve faster
Making proteinDepends on RNACan code for protein directly
Best suited forStoring genetic informationTransmitting genetic information
Step of the central dogma that makes itReplication (DNA from DNA)Transcription (RNA from DNA)Q
NEET 2021: the central dogma flow chart is replication, transcription, translation, protein. Transduction is not a step.

Watch out for (10)

Test yourself on a real paper

Sit a past NEET paper, timed and marked the way the exam marks it. You see your score and every answer the moment you finish. Free to start.

Sit a NEET past paper