PYQ Vault

MHT-CET Physics · Superposition of Waves

Organ Pipes, the Resonance Tube and the Doppler Effect

An open pipe has antinodes at both ends and sounds every harmonic of v/2L; a closed pipe has a node at the closed end and sounds only the odd harmonics of v/4L; end corrections lengthen the air column, and a moving source or listener shifts the frequency heard.

Why this matters

43 PYQs, sixteen HARD: now the densest-HARD page in the chapter. Three shapes: the frequencies and overtones of open and closed pipes (including a pipe dipped in water, which becomes closed), end corrections and the resonance tube, and the Doppler formula.

Concept 1 of 2: Open and Closed Pipes

An open end is free, so it is an antinode; a closed end is blocked, so it is a node. An open pipe fits half a wavelength and all its multiples; a closed pipe fits only a quarter-wavelength and its odd multiples — so it is an octave lower and missing every even harmonic.

Definition

  • Open: np=pv2Ln_p = \dfrac{pv}{2L}, all harmonics; ppth overtone = (p+1)(p + 1)th harmonic.
  • Closed: n=(2p−1)v4Ln = \dfrac{(2p - 1)v}{4L}, odd harmonics only; the ppth overtone is the (2p+1)(2p + 1)th harmonic. Its fundamental is half the open pipe's of the same length.
  • A pipe dipped in water becomes closed with the air length above the water: 80% immersed makes n2=v4(0.2L)n_2 = \dfrac{v}{4(0.2L)}.
  • End correction e=0.6re = 0.6r: open pipe length l+2el + 2e, closed l+el + e. Resonance tube: l1+e=λ4l_1 + e = \dfrac{\lambda}{4}, l2+e=3λ4l_2 + e = \dfrac{3\lambda}{4}.
  • A closed pipe's second overtone (5th harmonic) has 3 nodes and 3 antinodes.

Pipe frequencies

nopen=pv2L,nclosed=(2p−1)v4Ln_{\text{open}} = \frac{pv}{2L}, \qquad n_{\text{closed}} = \frac{(2p - 1)v}{4L}

Diagram · open pipe and closed pipe, first two modes

Open pipe: both ends antinodes, all harmonicsNAAfundamentalharmonic 1n = v/2L340 HzNNAAA1st overtoneharmonic 2n = 2v/2L680 HzClosed pipe: node at closed end, odd harmonicsNAfundamentalharmonic 1n = v/4L170 HzNNAA1st overtoneharmonic 3n = 3v/4L510 Hz

Both pipes are 0.5 m long, with sound at 340 m/s. The open pipe fits λ/2 and gives 340 Hz, 680 Hz, 1020 Hz (every harmonic). The closed pipe fits only λ/4, so its fundamental is half as high, 170 Hz, and there is no 2nd harmonic: its first overtone is the 3rd harmonic, 510 Hz, then 850 Hz. The blue curves show how far the air moves at each point.

Worked example

A 0.5 m pipe, sound at 340 m/s. Fundamental if open, and the first three frequencies if one end is closed?
Practise this conceptself-check · 3 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

MHT-CET · 2023 · 10th May Shift 1 · Q14Easy

Example 1 · Superposition of Waves · Pipes, Resonance Tube, and Doppler Effect

The pipe open at both ends and pipe closed at one end have same length and both are vibrating in fundamental mode. Air column vibrating in open pipe has resonance frequency n1n_1 and air column vibrating in closed pipe has resonance frequency n2n_2, then

Numbering a closed pipe's overtones like an open one's

A closed pipe has no even harmonics, so its first overtone is the 3RD harmonic and its second the 5th. Counting 2nd, 3rd as for an open pipe gives the wrong frequency every time.

One end correction for an open pipe

An open pipe has TWO open ends, so its effective length is l+2el + 2e; a closed pipe has one, l+el + e. Using l+el + e for an open pipe is the planted wrong wavelength.

Concept 2 of 2: The Doppler Effect

A listener moving toward the source meets the wave crests sooner; a source moving toward the listener crowds its crests together. Either way the pitch rises. A car sounding its horn at a wall is both: the wall hears a moving source, and the driver hears the echo as a moving listener.

Definition

  • n=n0v±vLv∓vSn = n_0\dfrac{v \pm v_L}{v \mp v_S}: upper signs when they approach each other.
  • Car at speed uu toward a wall, hearing its own echo: n=n0v+uv−un = n_0\dfrac{v + u}{v - u}.
  • Moving apart: both signs flip, and the pitch falls.

Doppler effect

n=n0 v+vLv−vS(approaching)n = n_0\,\frac{v + v_L}{v - v_S} \quad (\text{approaching})

Worked example

A 340 Hz source moves at 20 m/s toward a stationary listener; sound travels at 340 m/s. Frequency heard?
Practise this conceptself-check · 1 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

MHT-CET · 2023 · 15th May Shift 1 · Q4Moderate

Example 2 · Superposition of Waves · Pipes, Resonance Tube, and Doppler Effect

The driver of a car travelling with a speed V1V_{1} m/s towards a wall sounds a siren of frequency nn Hz. If the velocity of sound in air is VV m/s, then the frequency of sound reflected from the wall and as heard by the driver, in Hz, is

Putting the source's speed in the numerator

The LISTENER's speed goes on top, the SOURCE's underneath. Approaching means plus on top and minus below — both push the pitch up.

Summary — formulas & gotchas at a glance

A revision cheat-sheet for the formulas and gotchas above. Click any concept name to jump back to its full explanation.

Formulas (2)

  • Open and Closed Pipes

    Pipe frequencies

    nopen=pv2L,nclosed=(2p−1)v4Ln_{\text{open}} = \frac{pv}{2L}, \qquad n_{\text{closed}} = \frac{(2p - 1)v}{4L}
  • The Doppler Effect

    Doppler effect

    n=n0 v+vLv−vS(approaching)n = n_0\,\frac{v + v_L}{v - v_S} \quad (\text{approaching})

Watch out for (3)

Test yourself on Superposition of Waves

20 past MHT-CET questions from this chapter, timed at 18 minutes and marked the way the exam marks it. You see your score and every answer the moment you finish. Free to start.