PYQ Vault

NEET Chemistry · Organic Chemistry – Some Basic Principles and Techniques

Electronic Effects

How a bond breaks into free radicals or ions, the carbocations, carbanions, nucleophiles and electrophiles that result, the four ways electrons shift inside a molecule, and how hyperconjugation and resonance steady a carbocation.

Why this matters

Three NEET questions, all from 2024 or later, and every one is about a carbocation. NEET 2024 asked which of four carbocations is the most stable, settled by counting α-hydrogens. Re-NEET 2024 asked which effect lets a methyl group steady a carbocation. Re-NEET 2026 asked which filled orbitals steady the 1-phenylethyl cation.

Concept 1 of 3: Bond fission, reactive intermediates and reagents

A covalent bond is a shared pair of electrons, and it can break in two ways. If each atom keeps one electron, you get two neutral free radicals. If one atom takes both electrons, you get ions: a carbon that lost the pair becomes a carbocation, a carbon that kept it becomes a carbanion. These species live only for a moment, so they are called reactive intermediates. A reagent attacks them, or a molecule, according to where the electrons are.

Definition

  • Homolysis: each atom keeps one electron of the bond. It gives free radicals and needs heat or light.
  • Heterolysis: one atom keeps both electrons. It gives a carbocation (carbon with six electrons in its outer shell, positive) or a carbanion (carbon with eight, one of them a lone pair, negative).
  • A carbocation is sp² and flat, with an empty p orbital at right angles to its plane. A carbanion is sp³ and holds its lone pair in one of the four orbitals.
  • Stability of alkyl carbocations: (CH3)3C+>(CH3)2CH+>CH3CH2+>CH3+\text{(CH}_3\text{)}_3\text{C}^+ > \text{(CH}_3\text{)}_2\text{CH}^+ > \text{CH}_3\text{CH}_2^+ > \text{CH}_3^+, that is 3° > 2° > 1° > methyl. Alkyl free radicals follow the same order, 3° > 2° > 1°.
  • A nucleophile (nucleus seeking) brings an electron pair. An electrophile (electron seeking) takes one.
SpeciesChargeWhat it isExample
CarbocationPositiveCarbon with six outer electrons, sp², flat, with an empty p orbital(CH3)3C+\text{(CH}_3\text{)}_3\text{C}^+
NEET 2024 asked which of four carbocations, drawn as structures, is the most stable.
CarbanionNegativeCarbon with eight outer electrons, one pair of them a lone pair, sp³CH3−\text{CH}_3^-
Free radicalNeutralCarbon with one unpaired electron, made by homolysisCH3∙\text{CH}_3^{\bullet} (methyl radical)
NucleophileNegative or neutralGives an electron pair to an electron-poor atomHO−\text{HO}^-, CN−\text{CN}^-, H2O\text{H}_2\text{O}, NH3\text{NH}_3
ElectrophilePositive or neutralTakes an electron pair from an electron-rich atomCarbocations, and the carbon of a C=O group
A neutral molecule with a lone pair is a nucleophile; a neutral molecule with an electron-poor carbon is an electrophile.
Practise this conceptself-check · 4 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

NEET · 2024 · NEET (UG) 2024 — 05 May 2024 · Q71Moderate

Example 1 · Organic Chemistry – Some Basic Principles and Techniques · Electronic Effects

The most stable carbocation among the following is :

A carbocation has six electrons, not eight

The positive carbon has only three bonds and an empty p orbital, so it is sp² and flat. The sp³ carbon with eight electrons is the carbanion.

Electrophiles can be neutral

An electrophile only needs an electron-poor atom. The carbon of a C=O group is one, even though the molecule carries no charge.

The methyl cation is the least stable

CH3+\text{CH}_3^+ has no alkyl group to help it, so it comes last: 3° > 2° > 1° > methyl.

Concept 2 of 3: The four electronic effects

Electrons in a molecule are not shared evenly, and they shift in four ways. The inductive effect pulls or pushes them along the σ bonds. Resonance spreads π electrons and lone pairs over a conjugated system. The electromeric effect moves a whole π pair to one atom, but only while a reagent attacks. Hyperconjugation lets the σ electrons of a C-H bond spread into a neighbouring π bond or empty p orbital. Only the electromeric effect is temporary.

Definition

  • Inductive effect (I): a permanent shift of σ electrons towards the more electronegative atom, passed along the chain and fading quickly with distance. -I groups pull electrons: halogens, -NO2\text{-NO}_2, -CN\text{-CN}, -COOH\text{-COOH}, -COOR\text{-COOR}. +I groups push them: alkyl groups such as methyl and ethyl.
  • Resonance: when one structure cannot show a molecule, it is drawn as several canonical structures. None of them exists on its own; the real molecule is the resonance hybrid, more stable than any of them. The extra stability is the resonance energy.
  • Resonance effect (R): the shift of π electrons or lone pairs through a conjugated system. +R: halogens, -OH, -OR, -NH2\text{-NH}_2 give electrons to it. -R: -COOH, -CHO, >C=O, -CN, -NO2\text{-NO}_2 take electrons from it.
  • Electromeric effect (E): a temporary, complete move of a π pair to one atom of a multiple bond when a reagent attacks. When it works against the inductive effect, the electromeric effect wins.
  • Hyperconjugation: the σ electrons of a C-H bond on the carbon next to a π bond or an empty p orbital spread into it. It is also called no-bond resonance.
EffectElectrons move throughHow long it lastsExample
Inductiveσ bonds, weaker with each bond along the chainPermanentCl pulls electrons along the chain of CH3CH2Cl\text{CH}_3\text{CH}_2\text{Cl}
Resonanceπ electrons and lone pairs of a conjugated systemPermanentThe -OH lone pair spreads into the ring of phenol
ElectromericOne π bond, whose pair moves fully to one atomOnly while the reagent is attackingH+\text{H}^+ adding to a C=C bond
HyperconjugationC-H σ bonds next to a π bond or an empty p orbitalPermanentA methyl group on a carbocation or on a C=C
Re-NEET 2024: hyperconjugation is how a methyl group on the positive carbon steadies a carbocation.
Practise this conceptself-check · 4 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

NEET · 2024 · Re-NEET (UG) 2024 — 23 Jun 2024 · Q100Easy

Example 2 · Organic Chemistry – Some Basic Principles and Techniques · Electronic Effects

Methyl group attached to a positively charged carbon atom stabilizes the carbocation due to

Only the electromeric effect is temporary

The inductive effect, resonance and hyperconjugation are always present. The electromeric effect exists only while a reagent attacks a multiple bond.

A halogen is -I but +R

A halogen pulls σ electrons because it is electronegative (-I), yet its lone pairs can spread into a π system (+R). The two effects act in opposite directions.

Canonical structures are not real molecules

No single resonance structure exists. The molecule is always the hybrid, and it is more stable than any one structure drawn for it.

Methyl is +I, never -I

An alkyl group pushes electrons. A methyl group on a carbocation helps it by its +I effect and by hyperconjugation, not by pulling electrons away.

Concept 3 of 3: What makes a carbocation stable

The positive carbon has an empty p orbital. Anything that can feed electrons into that orbital spreads the positive charge and steadies the ion. A C-H bond on the next carbon can lean its σ electrons into it: that is hyperconjugation, and more such hydrogens means more help. A double bond or a benzene ring next to the positive carbon can feed in its π electrons: that is resonance. Either way the electrons must come from a filled orbital, because an empty orbital has nothing to give.

Definition

  • An α-carbon is a carbon joined to the positive carbon. Each H on an α-carbon is an α-hydrogen, and each can take part in hyperconjugation.
  • More α-hydrogens, more hyperconjugation, a more stable carbocation: CH3+\text{CH}_3^+ has 0, CH3CH2+\text{CH}_3\text{CH}_2^+ 3, (CH3)2CH+\text{(CH}_3\text{)}_2\text{CH}^+ 6 and (CH3)3C+\text{(CH}_3\text{)}_3\text{C}^+ 9. This is why 3° > 2° > 1° > methyl.
  • A C=C bond or a benzene ring joined to the positive carbon spreads the charge by resonance, so allylic (CH2=CH-CH2+\text{CH}_2{=}\text{CH-CH}_2^+) and benzylic (C6H5CH2+\text{C}_6\text{H}_5\text{CH}_2^+) carbocations are stabilised.
  • The empty p orbital takes electrons only from filled orbitals: filled C-H σ orbitals (hyperconjugation) and filled π orbitals (resonance).

Hyperconjugation count

number of hyperconjugating H=number of α-hydrogens\text{number of hyperconjugating H} = \text{number of } \alpha\text{-hydrogens}

Diagram · the carbocation stability ladder

classionα-Hcountmore stable3°(CH₃)₃C⁺9 α-H3 CH₃, +I2°(CH₃)₂CH⁺6 α-H2 CH₃, +I1°CH₃CH₂⁺3 α-H1 CH₃, +ImethylCH₃⁺none0 α-Hno CH₃Hyperconjugation in CH₃CH₂⁺C⁺HHempty p orbitalCHHHfilled C-H σ

Each dot is one α-hydrogen. An α-hydrogen sits on a carbon joined to the positive carbon; an H on the positive carbon itself does not count. Each C-H bond of an α-carbon can lean its electrons into the empty p orbital, so more α-hydrogens spread the charge more: 9 > 6 > 3 > 0 gives 3° > 2° > 1° > methyl. The CH₃ groups also push electrons by their +I effect.

Worked example

Count the α-hydrogens in (CH3)2CH+\text{(CH}_3\text{)}_2\text{CH}^+ and in (CH3)3C+\text{(CH}_3\text{)}_3\text{C}^+, and say which carbocation is more stable.
Practise this conceptself-check · 4 quick reps

The same idea in a real exam question:

NEET · 2026 · Re-NEET (UG) 2026 — 21 Jun 2026 · Q48Moderate

Example 3 · Organic Chemistry – Some Basic Principles and Techniques · Electronic Effects

The following carbocation (1-phenylethyl cation, C6H5-CH+-CH3\text{C}_6\text{H}_5\text{-CH}^{+}\text{-CH}_3) is stabilized by the interaction of the empty p orbital with

Count the H atoms on the next carbon, not on the positive one

A hydrogen on the positive carbon itself cannot hyperconjugate. Only hydrogens on carbons joined to it count.

Only filled orbitals give electrons

The empty p orbital is steadied by filled σ and filled π orbitals. Empty orbitals such as σ∗\sigma^* and π∗\pi^* have no electrons to give it.

Next to a ring or a C=C, count resonance too

A carbocation joined to a benzene ring or a C=C bond is also steadied by resonance, so do not judge it by its α-hydrogens alone.

Summary — formulas & gotchas at a glance

A revision cheat-sheet for the formulas and gotchas above. Click any concept name to jump back to its full explanation.

Formulas (1)

  • What makes a carbocation stable

    Hyperconjugation count

    number of hyperconjugating H=number of α-hydrogens\text{number of hyperconjugating H} = \text{number of } \alpha\text{-hydrogens}

Reference tables (2)

Bond fission, reactive intermediates and reagents5 rows
SpeciesChargeWhat it isExample
CarbocationPositiveCarbon with six outer electrons, sp², flat, with an empty p orbital(CH3)3C+\text{(CH}_3\text{)}_3\text{C}^+
NEET 2024 asked which of four carbocations, drawn as structures, is the most stable.
CarbanionNegativeCarbon with eight outer electrons, one pair of them a lone pair, sp³CH3−\text{CH}_3^-
Free radicalNeutralCarbon with one unpaired electron, made by homolysisCH3∙\text{CH}_3^{\bullet} (methyl radical)
NucleophileNegative or neutralGives an electron pair to an electron-poor atomHO−\text{HO}^-, CN−\text{CN}^-, H2O\text{H}_2\text{O}, NH3\text{NH}_3
ElectrophilePositive or neutralTakes an electron pair from an electron-rich atomCarbocations, and the carbon of a C=O group
A neutral molecule with a lone pair is a nucleophile; a neutral molecule with an electron-poor carbon is an electrophile.
The four electronic effects4 rows
EffectElectrons move throughHow long it lastsExample
Inductiveσ bonds, weaker with each bond along the chainPermanentCl pulls electrons along the chain of CH3CH2Cl\text{CH}_3\text{CH}_2\text{Cl}
Resonanceπ electrons and lone pairs of a conjugated systemPermanentThe -OH lone pair spreads into the ring of phenol
ElectromericOne π bond, whose pair moves fully to one atomOnly while the reagent is attackingH+\text{H}^+ adding to a C=C bond
HyperconjugationC-H σ bonds next to a π bond or an empty p orbitalPermanentA methyl group on a carbocation or on a C=C
Re-NEET 2024: hyperconjugation is how a methyl group on the positive carbon steadies a carbocation.

Watch out for (10)

Test yourself on a real paper

Sit a past NEET paper, timed and marked the way the exam marks it. You see your score and every answer the moment you finish. Free to start.

Sit a NEET past paper